DSLR Camera Shootout

DSLR Shootout

There’s never been a better time to move up from a compact camera or a super-zoom style fixed lens camera to a new DSLR than the present. Today’s camera manufacturers are introducing new models that feature great ease of use bundled with superior image quality, innovation and durability.

Among the most interesting features manufacturers are adding to their cameras is the ability to shoot full HD video. This is a compelling option, for more reasons than one. Are both your existing camera and camcorder getting a little old? Now, with the purchase of one new DSLR, you can replace both your old camera and your old camcorder, making these new DSLR’s a great value proposition. Plus, simply put, you won’t be able to get the same quality video from a consumer camcorder that you can with one of the new DSLRs from Canon, Nikon or Pentax. Why? The interchangeable lenses that work with these cameras are better, plus, the sensor inside the camera is much larger -- this works out to create beautiful cinematic video that you just can't replicate with most camcorders.

How do you pick which camera is best for you, especially with the blizzard of choices and options? Assuming that you don’t already have an investment in lenses for one camera system or another (which may drive your decision), we’ll take a side-by-side look at HD video capable consumer DSLRs from three top manufacturers: The Canon Rebel T2i, the Nikon D5000, and the Pentax K-X.

On to the comparison.

Canon T2i Nikon D5000 Pentax K-X
Megapixels 18 12.9 12.4
LCD Size 3.0 inches 2.7 inches 2.7 inches
LCD Tilt/Swivel No Yes No
LCD Resolution 1.04 million dots 230,000 dots 230,000 dots
Live View Yes Yes Yes
Video Resolution 1080p 720p 1080p
Video Frame Rates 24p, 30p, 60p 24p 24p
Fastest Shutter Speed 1/4000 sec. 1/4000 sec. 1/6000 sec.
Lowest ISO 100 100 100
Highest (Expanded) ISO 12,800 6,400 12,800
Shooting Speed (continuous) 3.7 fps 4 fps 4.7 fps
Built-in HDR No No Yes
Viewfinder coverage 95% 95% 96%
List Price $899.99 $629.95 $649.95
Total Points 8 4 7


What to take away from this comparison?

First, the clear winner when compared feature to feature is the new T2i from Canon's line of Rebel consumer cameras. This is a truly potent camera offering features that will satisfy even the "prosumer" market. But, that said, this may make the camera overkill for the average consumer. By all means buy this camera if you think you want to take photography seriously as a hobby, or if you want a camera to grow into -- in either case the T2i will not disappoint. And, if you want a camera that can put glorious full HD home movies on your big screen TV (or if you have the ambition to become an independent filmmaker), then the T2i is a no brainer in this class of camera with its full 1080p resolution and suite of available frame rates.

Still, is it the best bang for the buck? In this case, the surprising Pentax K-X has to get the nod. It's not the least expensive camera in this group, but at only $20 more than the Nikon D5000, it offers a surprising list of features. It offers the fastest continuous shooting speed in this group so you won't miss any of the action at the kids' sports events; for those interested in HDR photography, the K-X offers that in camera, and it matches the expanded ISO capability of the more expensive Canon. Plus, it comes in colors other than black for those looking to spice up their look. We particularly like the white and navy blue color options.

What about the Nikon? Its best feature is its articulating view screen. For shooting in awkward spots, either above the head or low, below the knees, this feature can help you get shots that otherwise might be difficult or impossible. Still, the D5000 is outclassed by the Canon T2i, which is no surprise given the extra $200 premium for the Canon. But what is most surprising is the fact that the Pentax K-X compares so favorably to not only the Nikon, but the Canon as well.

Overall, despite the Canon's technical prowess, when price is figured into the mix, the Pentax K-X is too compelling to ignore. In this case, Splashrate gives the nod, with certain reservations primarily related to video capability, to the Pentax K-X. It just might be your first best choice for moving up to DSLR shooting.

Wal-Mart.com USA, LLC
Twitter